| 1. | God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - Butch Baldassari, Traditional |
| 2. | We Three Kings - Butch Baldassari, Hopkins, John Henry |
| 3. | The First Noel - Butch Baldassari, Sandys, William |
| 4. | The Little Drummer Boy - Butch Baldassari, Davis, Katherine |
| 5. | Silent Night - Butch Baldassari, Gruber, Franz |
| 6. | Do You Hear What I Hear? - Butch Baldassari, |
| 7. | Beautiful Star of Bethlehem - Butch Baldassari, |
| 8. | Joy to the World - Butch Baldassari, Mason, Lowell |
| 9. | What Child Is This? - Butch Baldassari, Dix, William Chatte |
| 10. | O Little Town of Bethlehem - Butch Baldassari, Brooks, Phillip |
| 11. | O Holy Night - Butch Baldassari, Adam, Adolphe |
| 12. | Angels We Have Heard on High - Butch Baldassari, Traditional |
| 13. | Away in a Manger - Butch Baldassari, Traditional |
| 14. | It Came Upon a Midnight Clear - Butch Baldassari, Sears, Edmund Hamil |
| 15. | Deck the Halls - Butch Baldassari, Traditional |
| 16. | We Wish You a Merry Christmas - Butch Baldassari, Traditional |